SAEM Society for Academic Emergency Medicine
901 N. Washington Avenue
Lansing, Michigan 48906-5137
Telephone: (517) 485-5484
FAX: (517) 485-0801
E-Mail: saem@saem.org

Preparing a Presentation and Developing Speaking Skills
William H Cordell, MD, Indiana University School of Medicine-Methodist Hospital

 

Twain said, "It usually takes me more than three weeks to prepare a good impromptu speech." Most good public presentations, no matter how easy or spontaneous they look, require diligent preparation, as well as an understanding of the key principles of presenting—designing the message, engaging the learner, rehearsing the delivery, and mastering presentation skills and technologies.

Emergency medicine academicians speak to a wide range of audiences including colleagues, nurses, paramedics/EMTs, and the lay public. Academicians should be eager to give lectures because to teach is to learn. Presentations are an excellent opportunity for the presenter to learn, as well as gain feedback and insights from the audience, literally "road testing" the materials. Speaking before a group is also a great motivator to be well prepared. (I have a rule that I never give the same speech twice—i.e., no "canned" presentations unless it’s an emergency. Each speech is used as an opportunity to update my presentation and knowledge.)

Speaking to (and with) an audience is still one of the most effective teaching methods. Because it is "live," the presenter can ad lib, improvise, and adjust instantaneously to meet the needs of the audience. Importantly, conversation can be 2 way with valuable feedback gained from the audience. Although presentations are ubiquitous in healthcare education, public speaking is unfortunately learned, for better or worse, by imitation or trial-and-error. In this chapter, I will review the art of message design and discuss techniques for effectively communicating that message through oral presentations.

The Presenter’s Responsibilities

Consider a 1-hour presentation attended by 20 people. The "cost" is 20 human hours times the hourly value of each person’s time. That’s a lot of time and cost not to mention the effort required for each audience member to travel to the presentation and break up their day to do so. To justify this cost, the presenter must be well prepared and the information thoughtfully presented and pertinent to the listeners’ needs.

Apologies are an unacceptable way to begin a presentation and an admission of poor preparation. "I’m sorry, but some of my slides didn’t turn out so well." "I’m sorry I spilled all my slides on the floor." "I’m sorry I left my handouts in the office." Such problems waste the audience’s valuable time and get the presentation off on the wrong foot. For the well-prepared speaker, such problems should almost never happen.

"Lecture" vs. "Presentation"

A lecture is unidirectional and is typically perceived by the audience as boring. The word "lecture" connotes a scolding or reproof. In contrast, the presentation, as defined by Ron Huff, is a commitment by the presenter to help the audience do something—and a constant, simultaneous evaluation of the worth of that commitment by the audience. This definition emphasizes the audience’s, rather than the presenter’s, self-interest. In the presentation, communication is bidirectional with the audience showing and telling the presenter how he or she is doing.

Think back to all the presentations you’ve heard. What made the best ones so memorable? What made the worst ones so forgettable? The best presenters probably incorporated some or all of the following elements—humor, entertainment, simplicity, organization, connection with the audience, depth of knowledge, and ability to communicate. The elements of not-so-great lectures probably included poor preparation, monotonous delivery, encyclopedic information, and little interaction with the audience. (Table 1 presents a more complete listing of these elements.)

Designing the Message

Luisa Simone wrote, "Being a successful presenter means learning how to edit, structure, and illustrate your concepts in order to inform, influence – and entertain – your audience. You have to be part editor, part director, and part showman." The purposes of a presentation include conveying a message, distilling information, motivating a group, communicating a vision, and pointing the audience to additional learning resources.

To receive a message, the learner must remain awake, alert, and engaged. The presentation is not the time to become a "human encyclopedia" inflicting fact after fact on a numbed audience. Walt Whitman, in Leaves of Grass wrote, "The art of art, the glory of expression and the sunshine of the light of letters, is simplicity." Rather than say more, the presenter should say less, concentrating on 3-5 major points. Audiences appreciate distilled information and a "road map" for learning.

The key to designing an effective message is understanding who the audience is and researching their needs. The audience should be scouted in advance to determine their level of knowledge and educational needs. Put yourself in their place. What questions would you want answered? Better yet, if you have the time, conduct an informal survey of persons representative of your audience and ask them, "Which questions do you want me to address on this topic?"

I use a checklist to help me prepare for a presentation:

Techniques for Engaging the Learner

The presenter must overcome numerous diversions competing for the audience’s attention by employing techniques that make the message rise above the "background noise." Here is a listing of some of these techniques:

Participatory Learning

It has been said that we remember approximately 25 percent of what we hear, 40 percent of what we see and hear, and 75 percent of what we hear, see, and do. When learning becomes participatory or interactive, learners remember more for a longer time in a shorter time and have more fun. Techniques that I employ to increase audience participation include:

Tell Stories

Instead of listing facts, tell stories. The human mind is particularly receptive to information imparted through story telling. (Before the invention of communication technologies, human knowledge and wisdom was transmitted stories, myths, and epic poetry.) Interject relevant clinical cases and anecdotes. Stimulate the audience’s imagination through imagery.

Repetition

The presentation should promote long-term memory retention. Repetition of the 3-5 major points is the key to retention. Some wag once said that since the audience is paying attention only 25% of the time, the presenter must repeat everything 4 times during a 1 hour presentation.

Provide Breaks

The teacher’s role is to increase the student’s level of mental arousal and maintain their attention. The length of the lecture should as a rule be less than 55 minutes. As a courtesy, for prolonged sessions, the audience should be given a 5-10 minute stretch (ergonomic) break or "biological break" every hour. (I appoint one of the audience members to be time keeper and Champion-of-Breaks.)

Humor

Orlando Battista said, "The shortest distance between two jokes makes a perfect speech." Humor delivered with finesse is a wonderful way to engage the audience and hold their attention. But edit out anything that might be offensive. An offended, angry audience has stopped paying attention.

Never Read a Speech

The text of a speech should never be read. Reading is literally monotonous as it loses the dynamics of conversational speech. This is why "elevator music," intentionally stripped of dynamics, remains unnoticed in the background. (One notable exception to reading a lecture is the international meeting where translators need a script of the presentation.)

Other Techniques to Hold Attention

Practicing

Rehearsal is preparation time devoted to the most crucial and difficult parts of the presentation while simulating the actual speaking conditions as closely as possible. Practice should not be going through the presentation time after time. Instead, rehearsal time should be spent on the opening and closing of the presentation, pacing and delivery, and smoothing out rough spots.

Public speaking is much like flying a plane. Once the plane’s in the air, the flight is usually smooth and on "autopilot." It’s getting the plane into the air and landing it that are the most difficult tasks. Therefore, most of your rehearsal time should be spent on getting your presentation "launch" and "landing"—the first 60-90 seconds and closing 2-3 sentences. Script out the opening and closing of the presentations to help prevent getting "tongue tied" during these crucial times. Practice smooth transitions from one slide to the next as well pauses, where appropriate, for dramatic effect.

When rehearsing, simulate the actual speaking conditions or worst case scenario you are likely to encounter as closely as possible. When a professional football team is going to be playing in a noisy domed stadium, they conduct some of their practices with a public address system blaring crowd noises at the same or higher decibel levels they are likely to encounter. Demonsthenes, the renowned Greek orator, overcame his inarticulate, stammering pronunciation by practicing with his mouth full of pebbles.

Here are some other rehearsal tips:

Presentation Techniques

Managing Stage Fright

Among the things most feared by healthcare professionals are a certified letter from an attorney’s office, discovering that "60 Minutes" is interviewing your patients, and speaking in public. For many people, speaking in front of an audience, to paraphrase actor John Barrymore, is exactly like childbirth—they’re glad to get it over with. Fear of public speaking, which is almost universal, can range from "stomach butterflies" to "fight or flight" panic. The solution is to channel that fear to energize your presentation and motivate you to be well prepared.

Several "rituals" can be undertaken to reduce anxiety and bolster confidence:

"Pre-Flight" Checklist

Just prior to your presentation, go through a pre-flight checklist:

Beginning the Presentation

As you prepare to begin the speech, face the microphone and get "settled in." Take a few deep breaths…then smile. A smile conveys to the audience that you are having fun and happy to be with them. As we discussed earlier, never begin by apologizing as this only calls attention to shortcomings that might otherwise have been overlooked. Body language is important. Don’t lean against the podium or fidget nervously with the slide projector cord. And be aware that every time you lay something down on the podium, the microphone picks up the noise.

A strong opening, which should be assiduously rehearsed, is paramount. The presenter must establish his or her credibility, engage the audience, divert their attention from competing interests, and establish the purpose of the presentation in the first minute. If you get started without stumbling over your words, you’ll quickly gain confidence and likely "cruise on auto pilot."

Closing the Presentation

Never end a presentation with a feeble statement such as "Well, I guess that’s all I have" or conclude with an "Any Questions?" final slide. This is not the message you want the audience to take home. Instead, script out and practice a strong, slightly emotional concluding statement that leaves the audience with a vivid mental image.

Timing is Everything

There’s an old proverb that says, "It always takes a person much longer to tell you what he thinks than what he knows." As a corollary, the shorter the speech, the more difficult the preparation. In the case of the scientific oral platform presentation, each word and slide must be carefully chosen to stay within the allotted 10-minute time frame.

Practice to finish in less than the allotted time—nobody ever got mad at a speaker for finishing too soon. Never try to cram 11 minutes worth of material into a 10 minute space by speaking faster. Instead, take out slides, especially those where you have to explain a lot of bulleted points.

The Performance Factor

Be enthusiastic and interactive and let your personality show! One of the reasons the audience is listening to you (rather than reading the information) is they want to see your personality and hear your perspective. Be interesting, but avoid over-entertaining which may obscure your message. Finally, put as much energy into presenting to a group of 3 as you would to a group of 300.

Handouts

Handouts help promote long term retention and provide a reference source for the audience. Preparing handouts also compels the presenter to prepare the information of the speech well in advance. Handouts free the audience to listen (rather than scribble notes) and allow them to make supplemental notes in the margin. Handouts also help clarify detailed information (such as formulas or lists).

Presentation Technologies

The best audio-visual aid is you, the speaker. Presentations don’t need slides to be effective. Imagine what it must have been like to see and hear Mark Twain standing in front of an audience, without slides, microphone, or props, captivating the audience with humor, wit, and story telling.

The use of slides, either 35 mm photographic slides or computer projection slides, is ubiquitous. These presentation technologies are the double-edged sword of presentations. Used effectively, such technology can enhance the transmission of the message. Used ineffectively, presentation technology can obscure or bury the message. A badly organized speech cannot be salvaged by 4-color graphics.

Computer Projection

Computer projection systems, composed of a computer, presentation software such as PowerPoint, and a projection system, are increasingly being used in favor of 35 mm film slides. There are several advantages to computer projection. Changes can be made at the last minute. Messages can be broken into smaller units since cost per slide is not an issue as it is with 35 mm film slides. Computer projection permits the use of multimedia including sound and motion graphics (video). And other programs, such as a live Medline search or CD-ROM images, can be projected. Computer projection systems have also introduced new problems and last minute wrinkles. The ability to make last minute change can lead to procrastination and poor preparation, such systems are more complex than 35 mm slide projectors, and not all venues have the proper equipment or connectors

Elements of Slide Design

Here are some elements of style for designing effective slides:

Beware of Gimmicks

Have you ever watched a TV commercial you thought was extremely clever and entertaining then realized that you had no idea whatsoever what product or company it was advertising? The message was somehow missing, overshadowed by the presentation. Don’t obscure the message with gimmicks, avoid cliché, and always attempt to simplify. Before adding another element to a slide, ask "Does this element amplify the message or detract from it?" and "Is it consistent with the message?" Notorious gimmicks that can obscure the message include cheesy clip art, complex slide backgrounds, flamboyant color schemes, and vacation pictures.

Computer projection has opened up a new world of special effects, formerly limited to Hollywood, to the rest of us. These effects include animation, slide builds (where bulleted points fly into the picture one-by-one), and electronic transitions (where one slide fades or dissolves into the next). Used sparingly, builds and transitions create movement that can engage the audience’s attention. Overuse, however, can induce vertigo, nystagmus, and nausea. When it comes to employing electronic effects, simplicity again rules. "Just because we can doesn’t mean we should."

5 Take Home Points

In conclusion, effective presentations are based on the following 5 key principles:

  1. Designing the message.
  2. Understanding the audience and defining their needs.
  3. Using techniques to engage the audience.
  4. Telling stories and showing pictures.
  5. Employing presentation technology to enhance rather than detract from the message.

If you have previously found public speaking difficult or anxiety provoking, I believe the application of these 5 key principles will help bring success to your future presentations.

 

Recommended Reading

Ron Hoff: I Can See You Naked: A New Revised Edition of the National Bestseller on Making Fearless Presentations.1992, Kansas City: Andrews and McMeel.

Edward R Tufte: The Visual Display of Quantitative Information. 1983, Cheshire, Conn: Graphics Press.

Edward R Tufte: Envisioning Information. 1990, Cheshire, Conn: Graphics Press.

Edward R Tufte: Visual Explanations: Images and Quantities, Evidence and Narrative. 1997, Cheshire, Conn: Graphics Press.

Claudyne Wilder: The Presentations Kit: 10 Steps for Selling Your Ideas. Rev. and updated ed. 1994, New York: Wiley.

 

Return to the Faculty Development HomePage

Return to the [SAEM] HomePage